Just weeks after wrapping up its dramatic seventh season, popular dating series Love Island USA is once again the topic of conversation. Season-six fan favorites JaNa Craig and Kenny Rodriguez took to social media Tuesday to announce that they had ended their relationship, sending fans of the show into a spiral of hot takes and half-baked theories.

Craig and Rodriguez confirmed their split on Instagram Tuesday evening, with Craig blasting her now-ex-boyfriend as a “manipulative liar.”

After JaNa Craig and Kenny Rodriguez confirmed their breakup with cryptic statements, their costars offered further insight into the messy split.